The Night the Screen Died (and Nobody Cared): Our First Speaker Club LIVE

On Wednesday 4th November, six members of the Speak Like a Speaker Club stood up at Arts University Bournemouth and each painted a picture in a thousand words (give or take). I gave myself four hundred to introduce them. And somewhere in the middle of those four hundred, the big screen died! (More on that later.)

At the end of my intro, I asked the audience to give every speaker a big clap when they finished. Standing up and telling your story to a room full of people for the first time is one of the scariest things you can do, and six people were about to do it.

How our Bournemouth public speaking club began

The first Speak Like a Speaker Club met in March 2023, in the Malt House room at the Brewhouse and Kitchen in Southbourne. It was networking buddy, business owner and one of the six, John Jocham’s suggestion that a monthly drop-in would be helpful for anyone who had to speak for their work. And so, the sessions began as a place to exercise your speaking muscles. Turn up, have a go, get some feedback, go home. No pressure, no commitment.

However, it turns out some of the people who came to those early sessions (including John) were committed. They enjoyed the pressure and stayed.

A year ago, with a new home at Patch in Bournemouth, I decided to make the club a membership with more structure and added challenges. Despite the new format, at its heart, nothing’s changed. The club is still a rehearsal room and as I know from my years in theatre that’s the one place you’re allowed to mess up and make mistakes. That’s the point. You can’t find out what works until you’ve found out what doesn’t.

So, in our rehearsal room, members experiment and play. They try the story they’re not sure about. Tell the joke that doesn’t land. Forget their words, lose their thread and find it again. Then the group gives feedback: honest, generous, specific and, frankly, often therapeutic.

What I didn’t expect was how much they’d look after each other, giving genuine support and encouragement during rehearsals and on the night. And it showed in everything they wrote to me afterwards.

A series of 4 images showing speakers at a public speaking event

How did it feel?

I asked each speaker to send me their honest reflections on the evening. Here’s what came back.

Every single one of them started with a feeling of pride, not with a review of their performance. Vicci wrote that eighteen months ago she wouldn’t have had the confidence to stand up at all. Westrow described what he chose to speak about as a major milestone. Stewart was proud of himself and of the whole group. I’d told the audience the evening wasn’t an end-of-term test, but a celebration of what they’d already achieved.  Pride comes before polish. As Vicci put it: “It wasn’t perfect, but I never expected it to be.” Never expect perfection. It doesn’t exist.

Video is the most honest coach you’ll ever have. Don’t be afraid to watch yourself back. Everyone came away with something specific to work on. Stewart wants to sway less. Vicci wants more eye contact and a little more volume. Small, concrete, fixable. That’s what real progress looks like.

You know more than you think you do. When Vicci watched her video back, she noticed she was looking down at her cue cards for lines she already knew. The cards had become a comfort blanket. It’s one of the most common things I see. Nerves make us underestimate how well we’ve prepared.

A public speaker presents to an audience in front of a screen

Stewart and his hero, Dave Gahan

There’s more than one way to remember a talk. Westrow and Vicci both wrestled with learning their scripts word for word. For Westrow, trying to memorise was the only part of the whole experience he didn’t enjoy. Next time he’ll put more on cards so he can relax and enjoy speaking. Vicci found the parts that weren’t directly her own story were the hardest to hold on to, and she wants to try a memory journey next time, with snippets of the talk placed around the house. Neither of them is wrong. The lesson is to find the method that suits you, not the one you think you should be using.

Rehearse in front of real people. Two weeks before the event, Stewart could hardly tell his story without notes. After a dry run at Patch the week before, he felt ready. Rehearsing in your head is not the same as rehearsing to a room.

Let the audience in. On the night, Stewart’s talk changed again. He added things off the cuff and played off the audience’s reactions to his slides. They were on his side, and their reactions became part of the talk.

Courage is contagious. Vicci’s friends told her that hearing her story made them want to be more open about their own, rather than hiding away from it. That’s what happens when someone chooses to be vulnerable on purpose.

Don’t underestimate the opportunity. Christophe summed it up beautifully. He’s learned not to underestimate the chance to speak, or how much work goes into making the most of it. And now he’s safely on the other side, he can admit he really enjoyed it.

A female speaker in front of a screen presenting a talk.

Kerry and her Golden Thread

Back to that screen…

It went during my introduction, at a media university of all places. Christophe grappled with it along with a kind member of the university staff who stayed behind to help. Thankfully there was a TV as backup for the slides.

What struck me most was how calm everybody was. No histrionics. Nobody panicked. And once we got going, the audience’s experience wasn’t diminished one bit. They laughed in all the right places, clapped when they needed to, and were warm and supportive throughout. The interval was buzzing with people connecting and catching up. Nobody wanted to leave at the end. In fact, security had to throw us out. Which just goes to show the audience came for the speakers, not the slides. The slides are not the talk. You are.

What did I learn?

I’ll be honest, it’s been a while since I put on a ‘show’ and I admit I missed having a team – stage manager, lighting, sound engineers and front of house staff! The tech troubles ate the hour I’d planned to make sure everyone was settled and happy. The lighting wasn’t quite right, and with the slides in trouble, I didn’t want to start mucking about with walk-on music for each speaker.

But this was our first one, and I’ve learned a lot. Next time it’ll be a proper show. A dress rehearsal in the space beforehand, so everyone knows where to stand. Rehearsed transitions from talk to talk, whether that’s music or me introducing each speaker. And a fabulous finish, blackouts and all. All filmed and photographed to a high standard.

Our speakers deserve a performance, and next time that’s exactly what they’ll get.

What this means for you

Reading the feedback, the thing that stood out to me was that no two speakers had the same next step. One wants to stand still. One wants to look up from her cards. One wants a way of remembering that doesn’t fight the way his brain works. Same evening, same group, completely different fixes.

That’s why I’ll always say there’s no one-size-fits-all way to prepare a talk.

If you like the idea of a rehearsal room full of people cheering you on, come and join us at Speaker Club.

And if you’d rather start somewhere more private, somewhere you can be awful with nobody watching, that’s what my Power 90: 1-2-1 is for. Ninety minutes, one to one, focused on the one thing holding you back. No group, no audience. Just you, me and the bit you want to work on.

Book your Power 90: 1:1 here.

Or arrange a chat here.

An audience and speakers giving presentations

What’s next?

Every speaker said they’d do it again. Stewart wants a bigger audience (“bring it on!”). Vicci enjoyed delivering her speech, which she never thought she’d say. Westrow is already wondering which festivals we could join.

And for two of them, the next stage is already booked. Off the back of her talk, Kerry was asked by someone in the audience to give it again at an event they’re running next year on creativity. And Kerry has invited Vicci to speak at her work’s Navigating Neurodiversity staff network, where Vicci’s talk couldn’t be a better fit. That’s the thing about standing up and speaking – you never know who’s listening, or where one talk will take you next.

So, what have you been putting off because it scares you? Six people just showed it can be done. And if they can do it, so can you.

The next Speaker Club LIVE is already in the planning, with a proper rehearsal, proper lighting and a screen that works (fingers crossed). Want to be there, whether in the audience or up on stage? Register your interest here and you’ll be the first to hear the date.

Sign up to the newsletter for news, tips, techniques and offers delivered every other Friday.